Our story began with a passion for authentic Italian cuisine and a desire to create a warm and inviting space for our guests. We take pride in offering a menu filled with traditional dishes made from the freshest ingredients, as well as our homemade pasta that's prepared with love and care. At Matteo's Osteria, we strive to provide an unforgettable dining experience that reflects the true essence of Italian hospitality.
​
Over the years, our dedication has earned us recognition such as Maui’s Best Italian Restaurant (2025), Maui’s Best Chef and Best Italian Restaurant (2016), and the Ê»Aipono Silver Medal for Best Italian. We were also honored to be featured on Food Network’s Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives with Guy Fieri, a moment that showcased our passion to a national audience.
Our Founders
Chef Matteo Mistura, originally from Italy, brings his heritage and culinary expertise to every dish, blending traditional recipes with a fresh, local touch. Alongside him, his wife Gianna Mistura shares her warmth and dedication to hospitality, making guests feel like part of the family from the moment they arrive. Together, Matteo and Gianna have created a restaurant that not only celebrates Italian flavors, but also embodies the spirit of aloha here in Maui.
Crafting Culinary Delights
Born and raised on Maui, Executive Chef Jayven Jacalne-Bonilla leads the kitchen at Matteo’s Osteria with passion, dedication, and artistry. Inspired by his early experiences cooking alongside his father and competing in local culinary programs, Chef Jayven has built his career through hard work, creativity, and a deep respect for local ingredients.
​
Blending time-honored Italian recipes with bold, modern techniques, he brings out the rich flavors and aromas that define our cuisine. From handcrafted pastas to fresh island seafood and premium meats, every dish reflects his commitment to excellence and his connection to the community that makes it all possible.
Curating the Perfect Pairing
At Matteo’s Osteria, Manager and Wine Director Michael Russomanno ensures that every guest feels welcome and cared for from the moment they arrive.
With a refined knowledge of wine and an intuitive sense of hospitality, Michael curates pairings that elevate our dishes and enhance the dining experience. His guidance in selecting from our award-winning wine list transforms each meal into a celebration of flavor, balance, and discovery. Both in service and in spirit, Michael embodies the warmth and elegance that define Matteo’s Osteria.
